Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur could go head-to-head in the transfer market this summer as both North London rivals eye Newcastle United midfielder Sandro Tonali to bolster their midfields.
Transfer expert Fabrizio Romano has revealed that Spurs have joined Manchester City and Arsenal in the race for the Italian international, with Tottenham reportedly viewing him as the perfect signing to kick-start their rebuild following two successive relegation battles.
The Athletic has also reported that while Newcastle remain open to selling the 26-year-old, no formal bids have arrived yet. The Magpies are expected to demand a hefty price tag, with several top clubs monitoring the situation closely.
Both North London sides are preparing for major summer investment. Mikel Arteta has publicly committed to being bold in the transfer market, while Roberto De Zerbi has spoken of his desire to reshape his squad from the ground up.
The Verdict: Who Should Sign Tonali?
football.london’s journalists have weighed in with different opinions.
Alasdair Gold believes Spurs hold a key advantage in De Zerbi, whose Italian background and tactical vision could prove persuasive. At Tottenham, Tonali would be guaranteed to be the focal point of a revamped side, whereas at Arsenal he risks sharing minutes across multiple competitions. Gold also noted that Spurs have relaxed their wage structure this season, making them more competitive financially. His verdict: Tonali to Spurs.
Jake Stokes makes the case for Arsenal, arguing that landing Tonali would simultaneously strengthen Arteta’s side and block a key De Zerbi target. He adds that despite questions over regular starts, Tonali would still rack up more playing time at the Emirates given Arsenal’s heavier fixture schedule. Stokes also points to Arteta’s long-term stability compared to De Zerbi’s limited managerial track record. His verdict: Tonali to Arsenal.
Sam Truelove, while full of admiration for Tonali as one of the Premier League’s best midfielders, questions whether he is genuinely needed at either club. Arsenal’s midfield, already featuring Declan Rice and Martin Zubimendi, may not require him. And despite Spurs’ need for quality, their back-to-back 17th-place finishes are unlikely to appeal to a player of his ambition. His verdict: Tonali to Manchester City or Manchester United.
