Sports

Premier League panel rules on Bogle’s challenge that left Tel injured

Two of the five members of the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel believe Leeds United’s Jayden Bogle should have been sent off for his challenge on Tottenham winger Mathys Tel on November 7. Bogle caught the Frenchman’s heel during Spurs’ frustrating 1-0 defeat at Elland Road. Referee John Brooks judged the contact accidental and took no action, and Tel later left Yorkshire with his foot in a protective boot.

The panel has now given its verdict, and three of the five agreed Brooks got the original call right. The same three felt VAR was applied correctly, as the incident didn’t meet the threshold for intervention. VAR assistant Tony Harrington had decided against a review at the time, backing Brooks’ decision.

In publishing its findings on the Premier League’s website, the panel described the outcome as a split decision in favour of no red card. All agreed it was a foul. The majority felt Bogle was going in with his right leg, and his left leg then came down on the back of Tel’s ankle without the speed, force or intensity needed for serious foul play. They called the contact clearly reckless but below red-card level, while the other two members felt the challenge was dangerous enough to warrant a dismissal. Because the majority saw the challenge as reckless, they also didn’t consider the lack of VAR intervention a clear and obvious error.

Bogle clearly had no intention of hurting Tel, but his studs caught the winger’s ankle as Tel tried to play the ball with his right foot. Spurs boss Roberto De Zerbi later told BBC Radio 5 Live he had full confidence in the referee and VAR. He said he was surprised by the yellow card shown to Pedro Porro, which he felt was clear-cut, but wouldn’t offer a view on the potential red card and had nothing more to add.

The panel was unanimous on another incident, ruling 5-0 that Brooks was right not to give Leeds a penalty for a handball claim against Mateus Fernandes. All five also agreed VAR handled it correctly. In the first half, the £85million signing bent low to chest the ball, but home players and fans protested that it hit his arm.

Tottenham return on Saturday, hosting Ipswich Town as they look to bounce back from the Leeds defeat. They’ve won their last two home games, against Coventry City and Crystal Palace, but have taken just three wins from their 10 league matches so far, so getting back to winning ways is vital.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *